Readings for Week 2, Contemporary Research Methods

Creation-as-Research: Critical Making in Complex Environments

21/09/20 1:34 PM start time :

Chapman, O. & Sawchuk, K. (2015). Creation-as-Research: Critical Making inComplex Environments. RACAR : Revue d’art canadienne / Canadian Art Review, 40 (1),49–52. https://doi.org/10.7202/1032753ar

READING NOTES (H3)

  • creation as research
    • “ontological question of what constitutes research in order to make space for creative material and process-focused outcomes”
    • critical making, creation-as-research, practice-led research, digital humanities
    • Garnet Hertz – “how hands-on productive work—making—can supplement and extend critical reflection on technology and society” (open source hardware movements)
    • Tim Ingold – Making – “pays attention to what the world has to tell us”
    • Massumi/Manning – act of making – “places value on relational qualities instigated through making and highlights how unexpected and even unknowable its outcomes can be”
  • creation is not necessarily art, aesthetics part of every day life
  • critical disabilities studies, process of using technology as art participation to highlight inaccessibility grows beyond anticipated visions (megafone, mapping inaccessibility to collaborative-performance-resistance), reverberations
    • sense-based scholarship, making performance, staging events, holding workshops, crafting, (-ing, doing) as tools for learning about abilism

INTERESTING CITATIONS AND DEFINITIONS (H3)

Wittgenstein,

mobile media lab (mml),

Samuel Thulin, Griselda Pollock,

Media archaeolgy – https://alisonreikoloader.wordpress.com

Garnet Hertz, “Critical Making,” 2012, http://www.conceptlab.
com/criticalmaking. See also Matt Ratto, “Critical Making:
Conceptual and Material Studies in Technology and Social Life,”
The Information Society 27 (2011): 252–60.

Erin Manning and Brian Massumi, Thought in the Act: Passages in
the Ecology of Experience (Minneapolis, 2014).

An Encuentro, “part academic conference, part performance festival,”
is organized every two years by the Hemispheric Institute
of Performance and Politics. For Encuentro 2014, see http://www.
concordia.ca/events/conferences/encuentro-en.html.

For more information on the Performing Disability/Enabling
Performance working group at Encuentro 2014, see The Disability
Performance Working Group, “Work Group Statement,”
12 September 2014, http://mia.mobilities.ca/encuentro/workgroup-
statement/. Participants, in no particular order, included
Tamar Tembeck, Yvonne Schmidt, Carola Garcia, Janet Gibson,
Margaret Ames, Ashley McAskill, Danielle Peers, Faye Ginsberg,
Lindsay Eales, Kelsie Acton, Koby Rogers Hall, Maria Schirmer,
Heather Vrana, Véro Leduc, Laurence Parent, Jennifer Jimenez,
Stephen Sillett, Baraka de Soleil, and Eduardo Farajado.

POST-READ (H3)


Doing as a tool for scholarship, learning about the world by creating reverberations.

21/09/20 2:00 PM end time

W+L W/ Jessica Wyman

Grad Study Strategies

Reading Strategies

  • read beginning+end = good snapshot of reading
  • looking for content, structure, theoretical framework
    • how are arguments made
    • what are the nuggets of it
    • looking for gist of it
    • create space to ask questions
    • identify what you do not get
    • writing summary at end of text helps w/ info retention
  • handwriting is better for retaining info
  • give yourself a time limit so you do not take 4 hours to read a text (although some texts are just difficult)
    • better to skim than to deeply read small part
    • option: read every other paragraph
    • see if there are “steps” described in text that summaries how the writer will go through points
  • do not write huge amounts of notes while reading, find ways to distinguish (visually) between quotes, paraphrasing, own thoughts
    • ex – quotes with “quotations” or highlighting in text, paraphrase with (parenthesis), own thoughts with star…
    • // look up more strategies for this to make notes easier to search
  • keep in mind your future self and try to make discovery / finding old info easier for thesis

Discussion / Facilitation Strategies

  • strategies for nervousness
    • prepare powerpoint so no one is looking at your face
    • can cover camera with sticky, or cover view or own self (on screen) with sticky so you dont have to look at yourself
    • prepare before discussion
  • 10 minute time describes your presentation, discussion is unlikely to be 10 minutes
  • it is not illegal to look up other sources of information to give context, it is ok to talk about them in your discussion
  • things you might include: bio of author, how text fits into academia/what discipline, how text fits in with other texts
  • ask why is this text the first text of the class, why here and now, will it be easier or harder than other texts, how does this orient us in critical theory
  • ask questions, share what you did not understand and ask the class to discuss/help figure it out
  • use facilitation to find space to talk about the text

Internet search for humanities grad studies strategies

  • sq3r – survey text, form questions (ex from headings), read review recite
  • after reading text – what are main points? is it important to record them? (will you need it later?) Summarize in own words to help retain information.
    • titles of chapters/subsections help
    • think of pre-reading, reading, review
    • scan titles/headings/subheadings/topic sentences/graphics to prioritize info
    • do not skip preface it containts important info about author context, voice, objectives
    • for larger texts keep own table of contents to help with review
    • take note of what author provides at end ex: bibliography, glossary, key terms, index, appendices
    • take note of boldface and italicized word/phrases
    • questions – what will prof ask? what will come up in discussions? make connections to associations + what you have already learned
  • during lecture – take notes using shorthand and keywords.
  • after lecture – read notes and see if they make sense, if they don’t/you have questions, ask colleague or prof while it’s fresh.

Further Research

  • common strategies for distinguishing paraphrase, quotes, own thoughts
  • how to make powerpoints and share screen for Teams